More Reviews
REVIEWS Etrian Odyssey 2 Untold: The Faf Review
I dunno what a "Fifnir" knight is, but damn is he scary-lookin'. And his game... it's pretty damn good too.

Godzilla (PS4) Review
Godzilla fans enjoyed the recent film, but will they feel the same way about the new video game?
More Previews
PREVIEWS Sid Meier's Civilization: Beyond Preview
Fans were mad about Beyond Earth. Rising Tide should fix that.
Release Dates
NEW RELEASES Stick 'Em Up 2: Paper Adventures
Release date: Out Now

BlazBlue: Chrono Phantasma EXTEND
Release date: Out Now

Lost Dimension
Release date: Out Now

Goat Simulator
Release date: 08/11/15


LATEST FEATURES BAMF BABES #12: Talia al Ghul [Batman Arkham City]
"Thousands of warriors have fallen in pursuit of the Demon. Would-be successors have proven to be nothing more than children battling the enormity of creation."

Call the Fight: Dying Light Flourishes During Dead Island 2’s Woes
These two games were set up to compete, only for one to suffer an embarrassing defeat.

LEADERBOARD
Read More Member Blogs
FEATURED VOXPOP oblivion437 Update: I was unfortunately not aware of Shamus Young's severe criticism of Fallout 3 available here to link in the original piece and I regret that.  It dovetails rather nicely with what I've written and it's much better executed than my piece.  I strongly recommend anyone...

MEMBER BLOG

oblivion437 oblivion437's Blog
PROFILE
Average Blog Rating:
[ Back to All Posts ]
Prolegomenon to Reviews for the New Thief
Posted on Saturday, February 15 2014 @ 15:07:04 Eastern

Eidos Montreal have released a seventeen-minute video of the upcoming Thief.  GR has it posted here.

Mr. Osborn, in his remarks on the post notes that while it appears to promise a competent stealth title in the near future, he is not in position to judge its merits relative to the rest of the franchise.  This is a fair point and a good admission to make.  It reveals a problem, however.  Any review of this sort of game - a franchise reboot by a different team using different technology with different design philosophy and no general regard for the series as a whole and no creative input from the franchise creators - must be fully apprised of the franchise's roots in order to offer any kind of effective comparison.  It is not a question of resources or technical competence - all three games have community patches to make the software fully compliant with contemporary hardware (including widescreen monitors) and software.  The entire series is available for less than thirty dollars.

Any outfit looking to publish a review for the upcoming game therefore has no excuse for reviews written by staff not possessing the required knowledge to render a fully competent review.  The game launches in ten days.  If one were not furnished with a review copy and therefore obliged to wait until launch day to begin playing that provides one-and-a-half weeks to get through all three games.  That is plenty of time.

For purposes of illustration, let us imagine two journalists discussing the political situation in China on the basis of a government-sponsored tour.  Further let us suppose that neither of these journalists speak, read, or write a lick of Mandarin or Cantonese.  Would they not, then, write credulous and foolish stories?  Would they not be raked over the coals?  We don't need to imagine.  This really happened.  The two inept think tank wonderboys were Matthew Yglesias and Ezra Klein.  Their reports were staggeringly naive.  Ethan Epstein raked them over the coals.  The stakes here are far lower.  The barriers to entry are far lower.  A similar raking deservingly awaits anyone who signs off on a similar exercise in journalistic incompetence.
comments powered by Disqus

 
More On GameRevolution