Casual Difficulty: Do Games Need Stories?
Posted on Friday, September 3 @ 12:25:46 PST by Jesse_Costantino[Is it possible that the rise of the Evil Casual Gaming Empire isn’t such a bad thing after all? Casual Difficulty considers the effects—both good and bad—that casual gaming has had on hardcore gamers. Think of this semi-regular column as a peace pipe extended from our gnarled FPS-worn hands to the soft, innocent hands of our casual brethren and sistren. In this Casual Difficulty, a look at stories in games.]
In contrast to other narrative media—like novels, films, and comics—the majority of game stories seem like the grotesque product of a million adolescents furiously typing on a million greasy keyboards for a million awkward years.
There are a few notable exceptions, of course, but by and large game narrative hasn’t evolved as much in complexity compared to the medium’s other advances. Graphical effects, control mechanics, online functionality, and so on, have all progressed by leaps and bounds over the past three decades. But we’re all still killing ugly space aliens just like we were thirty years ago in Tempest, Galaga, and Space Invaders.
It’s distinctly possible that games just aren’t very good at telling stories.
We don’t play board games for the storylines, nor do we read poetry looking for profound plots. Both of these things can tell good stories—tabletop RPGs and epic poetry both tell great stories—but that doesn’t mean that they all should.
As I claimed in a prior column, one of the great boons of casual and social game design is that mass-market-friendly titles are turning back the clock to a time before games were unnecessarily complex. Part of this reinvention has been the ousting of typical game narratives.
Like every other gamer, I’ve become accustomed to the derivativeness of game storylines. Over the years, I’ve even grown to appreciate the subtle differences between them. From the perspective of a gamer, the alien invasion story of Half-Life 2 is worlds apart from the invasion story of Gears of War. But to a non-gamer, they may as well be the same game.
Just like controller complexity has alienated a large part of the population, so have the outlandish science-fiction storylines. But rather than ditching narrative altogether, casual genres like mini-game collections and social games rely instead on a sense of setting - a farm, outer space, a carnival, a kitchen, a tropical resort, a yoga studio, a suburban neighborhood, etc. - but not necessarily on plot.
Just in case you were sleeping, absent, or just plain spacing-out during your high school English classes, “plot” refers to the interrelated events within a narrative and “setting” to where and when those events take place. Both are aspects of storytelling, but as casual gaming is showing, games as a medium might be better suited to setting than to plot.
I won’t go into too much detail about why this is the case, but I will say briefly that—unlike every other storytelling medium such as novels or movies—games are defined by non-linearity. Even the most rigidly linear game needs a certain amount of wiggle room to allow players to make choices. Sometimes it’s as simple as choosing when to push a button (like in Dragon’s Lair); other times, it’s as complex as wandering about an entire continent and doing whatever strikes your fancy (like in Daggerfall). Similar to sports, video games depend on having a clearly defined space for things to happen, but not a scripted course of action.
The open-world and sandbox genres take setting very seriously. The skeletal story that weaves together Just Cause 2, for example, is nothing compared to the island itself. Or think about how vital the setting is to a recent critical darling like Batman: Arkham Asylum. Yes, these games also have plots, but comic books and TV shows could relay those same plots far better.
Destiny: Rise of Iron
Age of Triumph launch trailer. (1:35)
Dark Souls III
The Ringed City launch trailer. (2:33)
Riders of Icarus
Corruption of Light Update Official Trailer. (0:51)
Toukiden 2 unleashed this Friday trailer. (2:49)
SAMURAI WARRIORS: Spirit of Sanada
SAMURAI WARRIORS Spirit of Sanada gameplay video. (1:36)
|More On GameRevolution|