GR Showdown: PS4 vs. Xbox One - Do Graphics Even Matter?
Posted on Friday, July 5 @ 15:00:00 PST by GR_Staff
GR Showdown pits the Game Revolution staff against each other in a passionate debate on a particular hot-button gaming topic. Our self-imposed rules? There is no middle ground—all must take a side. All debates will have an equal number of representative on both sides: either 1-on-1 or 2-on-2 . And all our arguments must be made in 350 words or fewer; 500 or fewer, if it's 1-on-1. Which side are YOU on?
This Week's Topic:PS4 vs. Xbox One - Do Graphics Even Matter?
Nick Tan - Yes: My first inclination is to be the rebel and say that all of the flame-bait articles comparing PS4 and Xbox One screenshots (you know, they're going to get over 1000 degrees on N4G, right?) are meaningless. Why bother with graphics when so many other things like DRM matter more to consumers. But that's the rub: They apparently do matter. Better to accept it and understand the reasons why.
Graphics matter because our eyes matter. Ifby chance multiplatform games are generally better rendered and modeled, have a more consistent and higher frame-rate, and have fewer graphical glitches on one platform over another, that can make the difference between which version of the game consumers will purchase. Hardcore gamers, despite our misgivings about one platform or another,are the crowd with the higher likelihood to own multiple consoles, so graphics are worthy of consideration.
If Sony's claim that the PlayStation 4 has stronger graphical capabilities than the Xbox Oneturns out to be true—and third-party developers notice and acknowledgethe difference—that's a major boon in the console war. It tells consumers that they are likely getting more bang for the buck in terms of hardware. That's why console specifications are such a hotly debated topic, particularly before both consoles havebeen released.
An overall impression is what's at stake, a battleground that is contended in a place one might not expect when considering graphics between platforms: exclusives. Though consumers have no other platforms versions to compare them to, there's an underlying, subconscious comparison between one console's exclusives to another'sand a graphical impression always comes to mind.
In fact, the real victim in this battle between the Xbox One is the PS4 is the Wii U.One of the main reasons the Wii U will haveissues with getting third-party support is merely based on the console's graphical specs to the Xbox One and PlayStation 4. It isn't a fair comparison, but as we head into the next generation, the lack of graphical power on the Wii U will force leading developers to choose whether it's worth thetime and money in developmentto create aWii U port of an Xbox One/PS4 title that inevitably won't look as appealing to them or to consumers.
Just becausegraphics may be an overrated factor, by virtue of usually beingthe first impression we see of a game through screenshots and trailers, doesn't devalue the fact that it is still a factor. Even if one console doesn't win over another in terms of graphical capabilities, the battle will push all developers and lead us to a gamingage closer to photorealism than ever before.
Fallout 4: Nuka-World
Fallout 4 Nuka-World trailer. (1:47)
Divinity: Original Sin II
Divinity Original Sin II latest trailer. (1:03)
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
GAME OF THE YEAR Edition announcement. (0:30)
Dark Souls III: Ashes of Ariandel
Dark Souls III Ashes of Ariandel official trailer. (2:39)
South Park: The Fractured But Whole
Nosulus Rift Experience. (2:20)
|More On GameRevolution|