GR Showdown: Should Grand Theft Auto Have A Female Lead Protagonist?
Posted on Tuesday, September 17 @ 12:40:00 PST by GR_Staff
GR Showdown pits the Game Revolution staff against each other in a passionate debate on a particular hot-button gaming topic. Our self-imposed rules? There is no middle ground—all must take a side. All debates will have an equal number of representative on both sides: either 1-on-1 or 2-on-2. And all our arguments must be made in 350 words or fewer; 500 or fewer, if it's 1-on-1. Which side are YOU on?
This Week's Topic: Should Grand Theft Auto Have A Female Lead Protagonist?
Nick Tan - YES: I imagine that the brunt of the charge against this call for a female lead protagonist in gaming, not onlyGrand Theft Auto V, is that it would beforced. It's the same viewpoint those hold against affirmative action in university acceptance policy, because it tarnishes meritocracy for the sake of diversity. Some would also say it's just the nature of the beast, given that game designers and market researchers understand that the majority of gamers are predominantly male. There is an inherentself-perpetuating cycle of female exclusion, in part due to the video game space being perceived as a generally masculinepursuit.
That's the argument presented by the developers of Grand Theft Auto V in a recent comment by Rockstar's Dan Houser that "being masculine was so key to the story." But this isan overlysimple view:Thatman is masculine and womanis feminine, and that's the end of it.I would argue that a man acting "like a man" is notas masculineasa womanacting "like a man,"because if a woman isto lead a gang typically comprised ofmen, she must show more grit and violent behavior as to eliminatethe presumptions about her gender being weaker and less capable of leadership.
In this role, awoman would express masculine traitswith more intensity,thereby highlighting whatthose masculine traits are. In other words, amale being masculine is by default, buta woman being masculine is by choice, and choices speak loudest when they are against the status quo. Casting a woman would also have more potential for drama andcomplexity, particularly for situations where she must be both a woman and a man in separate yet sometimes similar roles.
Now, it's understood that the main reason there are few female leads in gaming is due to businessmen peering through the data and concludingthat female leads generally don't garner money. But the Grand Theft Auto series is grand and prolific enough that having afemale protagonist wouldn't diminish its sales much so long as the gameplay and story remain solid. And for Grand Theft Auto V, which touts its cast of three protagonists, would seem to have been the best opportunity to do so. Alas, it's not to be, but that doesn't mean Grand Theft Auto VIcouldn't, and casting a female lead in such a series would be a courageous statement (hopefully one that doesn't come with too many jiggling beasts and ass cheeks).
Anthony Severino - NO:Let me preface by saying that I have absolutely nothing against a female main protagonist in a video game. If anything, I’d like to see a lot more females in strong lead roles, rather than being cast as a side-kick, supporting a male lead who must protect her with his life. But when it comes toGrand Theft Auto V, there is no place for a female lead and that’s due to one thing: testosterone.
Rockstar Games is painting a certain picture withGTAV—one filled with risk, vulgarity, crime, and ruthless killing. That’s not to say women are not capable of such things, but men are far more likely thanks to the testosterone coursing through our veins.
Men, thanks to the male sex hormone, generally take more risks, commit more crimes, are much more aggressive, and are more likely to commit murder. This isn’t just an assumption—it’s a fact. Multiple published studies have found that higher testosterone levels were found in those who commit violent crimes versus those that commit non-violent crimes. And the proof can be found in this country’s prison system, where nine times as many men have faced hard time in State or Federal prison. Males have committed 90% of homicide cases in the United States—91% of which are gun-related homicides. On the flipside, proving that men engage in riskier situations, men are three times more likely to be murder victims, and more likely to be victims of drug- and gun-related homicides.
Despite how much the story and characters ofGrand Theft Auto Vhave been over-dramatized, they fit a specific description and pattern found in men, not women. When you’re a publisher like Rockstar Games and you’re looking to create the crowning achievement of an entire video game generation, believability needs to be at its core, even if it is indeed a fantasy situation. And even though there are ruthless women who have committed crimes deadlier and more atrocious than many men, it’s nowhere near as common or believable, and just wouldn’t fit the world Rockstar Games has created—a world and game named after a felony crime.
Fallout 4: Nuka-World
Fallout 4 Nuka-World trailer. (1:47)
Divinity: Original Sin II
Divinity Original Sin II latest trailer. (1:03)
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
GAME OF THE YEAR Edition announcement. (0:30)
Dark Souls III: Ashes of Ariandel
Dark Souls III Ashes of Ariandel official trailer. (2:39)
South Park: The Fractured But Whole
Nosulus Rift Experience. (2:20)
|More On GameRevolution|