More Reviews
REVIEWS Firefall Review
Repetitive gameplay makes this fall a little boring.

The Walking Dead: Season Two Review
At this point, you’re not coming back for the zombies. Let’s get down to business.
More Previews
PREVIEWS Geometry Wars 3: Dimensions Preview
Put up some movie glasses, because Geometry Wars is entering the third dimension.
Release Dates
NEW RELEASES Destiny
Release date: 09/09/14

FIFA 15
Release date: 09/23/14

Ar Nosurge: Ode to an Unborn Star
Release date: 09/23/14

Persona 4 Arena Ultimax
Release date: 09/30/14


LATEST FEATURES And I Was All "Hell Yeah I'll Play a New Dreamcast Game"
I just played a Dreamcast game that was released in... wait, 2014?

A Comprehensive Guide to Dealing with Controversy in the Video Game Industry
Need help wading through the latest misogyny/homophobia/racism/corruption debate in the gaming industry? Paul Tamburro’s here to help!
MOST POPULAR FEATURES The Updating List of PAX Indies
We're heading to PAX Prime! Are you looking to check out a few unique indie games while you're there? UPDATED: Dragon Fin Soup, Dungeon of the Endless,

LEADERBOARD
Read More Member Blogs
FEATURED VOXPOP samsmith614 Since game design is a business, I decided to see what's really selling well for the PS4. I did this search a week ago, and at the time, out of the top 20 bestsellers on Amazon 10 had not even been released yet. By now some have been released. But others still have not. And yet others...

DAILY MANIFESTO

The Truth About Game Revolution

Posted on Tuesday, December 4 @ 22:17:31 Eastern by JP_Hurh
After reading the comments on Duke’s recent blog, I decided to weigh in because so much of it veered to what people liked and disliked in GR’s reviews.  The truth is, most of the writing you see on GR is done without pay, and the few staff that are on payroll have to wait an outrageous amount of time for checks that may never come.  We try to be as honest as possible in our reviews, but we also are given a wide leash to try new styles of writing, to swing for the fences, as it were.  What GR offers us as journalists is creativity, but that comes at the expense of money.  And money is expensive.

So you don’t have to worry about our reviews being influenced by money or by game publishers.  But that doesn’t mean GR is infallible.  GR doesn’t always get advance copies of games that are made available to other, more well-trafficked, sites.  We have absolutely no marketing, we exist almost entirely through word of mouth, and we only get attention when we manage to piss someone (or some culture or some sovereign nation) off.   

But this also means that we have to rush to review games, especially during the holiday season, with little editorial oversight or pure zen reflection.  We do the best we can, but we make mistakes.  The constant drinking and zombie parades probably don’t help.  

Above and beyond the occasional factual mistakes, all game critics, I am sure, have second-guessed their final marks.  Sometimes games look better or worse from a different vantage.  My old review of Chromehounds, for example, has both kinds of regrets.  On one hand, there’s the embarrassing error near the bottom, but on the other hand, there’s the fact that I kept thinking about the game long after the review.  Don’t get me wrong, I wouldn’t change a single word of the text.  But I might, given some hindsight, have bumped the grade up a half point.  Of course, I haven’t played the game in over a year, so maybe my first impression was the more informed one.

And this brings me to my point, which is that grading is probably the least reliable thing on this site or any other.  In the substance of game reviews we try to describe the game, try to point out what most people would like or not like, try to suck the marrow out of the game and then regurgitate it for you, our little baby bird readers. But giving a game a final grade is the most painful process; it reduces all our careful words to a single letter and gives the impression of some gestalt transcendent judgment that all of us know (well, maybe not all game journalists know it) does not exist.

The difference between GR criticism and that of other sites is that we try to make reading game reviews as painless an activity as possible.  That, and we have a sense of perspective.  Granted, it is the perspective of a drunk homeless guy on a sunny afternoon in the park, but at least you can’t smell us over the internet.

So, how does GR grade in your book?


comments powered by Disqus

More On GameRevolution