More Reviews
REVIEWS Samurai Warriors Chronicles 3 Review
Have you played Dynasty Warriors or Samurai Warriors before? Of COURSE you have. So what makes THIS one different?

FINAL FANTASY XIV: Heavensward Review
Final Fantasy XIV's first expansion has arrived, and it delivers a new adventure with plenty of dragons to battle.
More Previews
PREVIEWS Etrian Odyssey 2 Untold: The Faf Preview
Etrian Odyssey 2 Untold: The Fafnir Knight has a long name, but don't make fun of it. It can kick your ass.
Release Dates
NEW RELEASES Lost Dimension
Release date: 07/28/15


LATEST FEATURES Why Some Games' Graphics Age Well (And Why Shenmue & Castlevania SotN Are So Special) - Best Video Game Podcast Ep 6
Lotta people talking about Shenmue. What makes its open world different from others? And how did its graphics end up aging really well? Let's discuss.

Rhapsody: A Musical Adventure - Old Games With Grandpa Heath: The Musical
The song intentionally has no tune or flow or purpose. That's the joke. It's about how the game is... I mean, just watch the damn video and you'll get it.

LEADERBOARD
Read More Member Blogs
FEATURED VOXPOP whytenoiz ~~        When I was eleven years old, it was a very good year, and I can remember my daily routine vividly. These were the years before I owned a Sony Playstation, and I used to venture to my friends house - everyday after school - to watch him play through Final...

DAILY MANIFESTO

The Truth About Gamespot

Posted on Friday, November 30 @ 19:18:37 Eastern by Duke_Ferris
As some of you may have heard, Gamespot has terminated their long-time reviewer Jeff Gerstmann, ostensibly over his Kane & Lynch review, and Eidos subsequently pulling their advertising dollars.

It's impossible for a company as large as C-Net (Gamespot's corporate overlords) to keep such a thing completely quiet, and I have sources that confirm that this is in fact true.

That's really a shame, and it puts Gamespot into an awkward identity crisis. I generally trust Gamespot's reviews over most other sites. I find them to be tedious and boring, but in the end, usually accurate. Or at least I used to.

IGN got caught last year changing scores for Nintendo games, just as Nintendo announced that the Wii would license IGN's Gamespy service. Play magazine's reviews range from fluffy to cuddly, and Game Informer has all the journalistic integrity of this prostitute.

So will GR end up the last bastion of honesty? If so, will we lose our advertisers?

I myself was unfavorably compared to Jeff in the deluge of hate mail I received for my Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess review. And I am told that he was not fired for giving the game a 6, but that it was his "tone". Admittedly it's a little mean.

Of course we're no strangers to mean at GR, recently comparing the Beowulf game to poisonous, off-brand, Chinese cough syrup, just for example.

But that's almost worse because the Gamespot writers are now unsure what it is that they can write and what will get them fired. Are Gamespot reviews going to get even blander? Is that possible?

However, I promise you the timing of all this is no coincidence.

Game publishers used to be very professional, taking bad scores in stride and moving on. But as the stakes have grown, they are clearly now trying to see how far they can flex their muscles to control the criticism industry. I rarely used to get calls or emails from publishers, complaining about the grades we give and demanding new reviews. However, in the last year, it has become almost commonplace.

Just a few days ago, another, different C-Net editor phoned me to confirm a number of facts because of all the abuse he was taking from publishers over low scores.

So Gamespot management has clearly been taking a lot of heat from publishers and advertisers. For example, I am told that Sony was quite upset over the 7.5 score for Ratchet & Clank Future, and so losing all of Eidos' ad dollars was clearly the final straw. It was also the final nail in Jeff's coffin.

Don't get me wrong, there may have been a number of other reasons to fire Jeff Gerstmann. I am told he wasn't the best worker, or their most talented writer. You may be a fan of his or you may not.

However, firing him specifically over Kane & Lynch was a stupid mistake on the part of his bosses. It has undermined Gamespot's credibility and disheartened the staff. Apparently, the Gamespot and Eidos forums are getting hammered by angry gamers.

Come to think of it, Gamespot might actually see more traffic because of the controversy. At least for today. But what about tomorrow?



comments powered by Disqus

More On GameRevolution