: Gorgeous graphics and animation, great use of the touch screen, deep story with memorable characters
: Story is convoluted at the end, poor difficulty balancing, too much trial and error, more talking than gameplay, gets redundant after a while
The last great game I remember playing where you were a ghost was Geist for GameCube. Ghost Trick may not be an action packed shooter, but it does have an interesting story with whacky characters and fun mechanics. You are trying to solve a murder mystery of yourself. You wake up as a ghost out of your body and need to find out who killed you and why. As you play through the 17 chapters the story unfolds more and more and starts out as a gripping story until the very end where it just falls apart and becomes hard to follow. Despite that the game has great art and animation and is worth a play through.
The main mechanic is playing as a ghost and being able to rewind time, change people's fates, and manipulate objects. When someone dies you can talk to their core where you find out a little about them, you can then rewind time to 4 minutes before their death. Once you see the clip it plays out again but you must manipulate objects to prevent their death. This is a really neat mechanic and very original. These all are puzzles and they get harder as the game moves on. One person may end up dying from a trap that was set up and you have to stop one part of that trap before the person is killed. When you are in the ghost world time stops and you can see all the objects you can hop too. However, you have a limited reach so you need to manipulate other objects to get closer such as knocking stuff down, opening things, and various situations like that. The puzzles end up becoming multiple screens and you some times have to travel to whole new areas mid puzzle. You can travel around via telephone lines, but you must be at the phone when someone calls at a critical time to trace the call. This is all really neat and fun, but after a while it kind of gets stale.
I hate to say this because this is a one of a kind game on DS. It uses the touch screen in a unique way, but all you do are these ghost puzzles. There's more talking than gameplay which will bore impatient people. Some cut scenes can go on for nearly 20 minutes. When you do start playing you are constantly interrupted with overly drawn out dialogue to tell you what to do. A lot of the times the puzzles can be nearly impossible to figure out or require constant trial and error. The occasional puzzle is thrown out there that is different -- some are timed and some aren't. Towards the end you get to play as two different ghosts, the other has the ability to swap objects. This adds another layer of depth and difficulty to puzzles, but most can be figured out after a few tries.
I actually got really attached to the characters which is surprising. For the long length of the game (nearly 20 hours) the characters were well developed, but the big flaw was revealing everything at the final 3 chapters then adding another complete twist at the very end to over complicate the story. It all flows perfectly fine until the end where it just falls apart. It gets so confusing with all the characters and details you have to remember, they should have spread it out more. Despite this major flaw this remains one of the most story rich games on DS. There are many puzzles in the game and it is well worth a purchase, but the impatient may not like it.
Overall, Ghost Trick is a unique game with original game mechanics that are repeated way too often. The story and characters are great and memorable, but the story falls apart towards the end and gets convoluted. There also is zero replay value because there's no collecting and no extra endings. Once you beat the game you are done for good. I also didn't like the poor balancing of puzzle difficulty and the high level of trial and error. If you can look past all this you are in for one of the best games the DS has to offer.