More Reviews
REVIEWS Final Fantasy XIV: A Realm Rebor Review
Just a small update to the existing review for the PS4 version of the game. What are the benefits to upgrading? Check here to see. ~Ed. Nick Tan

Cut the Rope: Triple Treat Review
Cutting the ropes has never before made gravity so… pricey.
More Previews
PREVIEWS Sniper Elite 3 Preview
Sending bullets through the hate.
Release Dates
NEW RELEASES Trials Fusion
Release date: Out Now

The Amazing Spider-Man 2
Release date: 04/29/14

Bound by Flame
Release date: 05/09/14

Wolfenstein: The New Order
Release date: 05/20/14


LATEST FEATURES 4 PAX Indie Titles to Look Out For
We've given attention to all the higher profile games at PAX EAST, but now it's time for the indies.

Ouya's Best Games Coming to the Platform
The Kickstarter console is slowly establishing itself with a couple of creative gems on the way.
 
Coming Soon

LEADERBOARD
Read More Member Blogs
FEATURED VOXPOP shandog137
So much more than war...
By shandog137
Posted on 04/18/14
The recent blog, Peace in the Era of Call of Duty  really made me think about war games that dig deeper than simply a kill streak reward. The first game that came to mind was Spec-Ops: The Line and although I haven’t played it, I began to wonder if it did the war genre as...

Gothic II Member Review for the PC

Lord_Fornelius By:
Lord_Fornelius
04/08/08
PRINTER FRIENDLY VERSION
EMAIL TO A FRIEND
GENRE  
PLAYERS 00 
PUBLISHER  
DEVELOPER  
RELEASE DATE  
M Contains Blood, Language, Sexual Themes, Use of Drugs, Violence

What do these ratings mean?

Them Germans sure love mediocre RPGs

Gothic II first impressions: If you ever read my reviews, you would know that the worst game I ever reviewed (other than FFVII) was Gothic. Gothic was an incredibly tedious and difficult RPG, which made controlling your catnip-addicted cat a much easier task. Now, I'm heer to give my opinion on the sequel. Now, you may be wondering "why did you bother to play a game that's the sequel to one you despise?". Well, It's a long story, but I actually purchased Gothic II years before I purchased the original (which I was interested in at the time).

Anyway, lets get on with the review. Just like with the original Gothic, It's fun for the first moment, but then it turns into a tedious and frustrating experience. The main problem I had with the original was the extremely confusing controls. Thankfully they have been improved and are now more streamlined than the original (from now you will not be required to press crtl + up arrow key just to buy items). However, that does not mean that the controls are good in general. There's no cursor to select items, and you have to increase your mouse sensitivity to a maximum in order to get the (mouse-controlled) camera to work well.

                             Gothic II

Another problem I had with the original Gothic was the incredible slow pace to make any progress. Unfortunately they didn't solve this problem at all, which means that it would take hours just to complete a simple quest. The cause of this problem is contributed to two things: the difficulty and the weak character customization. You see, fighting enemies requires more trial by error than skill.

In the original Gothic, to fight enemies you had to use this complicated and unresponsive fighting system. This system is still available in the sequel, but thankfully you can change it to make fighting require nothing more than clicking on the left-mouse button. Sadly though, even with the button mashing option, the controls are still unresponsive. Even if it were responsive, the battles would still be incredibly difficult due to, what appears to be, the steroid-addicted animals that roam around the world, that you would fighting. In fact, one of the most difficult enemies that you will encounter is a rat.......that's right the monster that's used as a target dummy in most RPGs is now the equivalent of Darth Vader. And since most of the enemies you will encounter are animals, it's impossible to block their attacks (for whatever reason).

                                Gothic II

This is made more difficult due to the slow-paced character customization. You see, to actually do well in combat, you have to purchase strong equipment, sadly though it costs allot of money, and you have to meet the statistical requirements that are needed to equip the item. Sadly though, in order to meet these requirements, you have to go to these trainers to...well... train you (just like in the original). The problem with this is that every time you reach a level, you are given only 10 skill points and in order to make any significance in a certain statistic, you have to spend 5 skill-points. In other words, you can only choose to increase two stats every time you level-up. But in order to level-up, you have to kill monsters, but you can't because you don't the proper equipment, but you can't buy them because you don't have the required statistics, which you don't have because you didn't level up. GAWD DAMMIT !!!!! So instead you'll be spending most of your time completing these boring fetch quests just to level up.

Another problem I had with Gothic II are the choices available for completing quests. Yes, your options for completing these quests are diverse, and each contain their own rewards. Sadly however, there's no moral or reputation system implemented, which makes you feel that being a Goody-too-shoes throughout the entire, had no real purpose. For example, you are tasked to capture a theif that stole only to survive in this capitalistic society. You could either let him go with no rewards, or capture him to get money from the militia. So what was the whole point of letting the theif go in the first place, if I didn't increase my morale.

There are some good things to say about Gothic II however. You can join 3 guilds that effect the storyline and progression of the game....and.....there are small improvements over the controls.

You maybe wondering why I typed in "first impressions". It's because I was so bored and frustrated with Gothic II, that I stopped playing, and wrote this review to express my hatred.

I don't understand why the Gothic series is popular over in Germany. Maybe because no other RPG has ever been published over there, and they find comfort playing this generic version of one. Either that or "Piranha Bytes" is cashing in on the Gothic-subculture that's growing in Germany.

                                  Gothic II


More information about Gothic II
 
D- Revolution report card
Views: 599 Review rating:
comments powered by Disqus

More On GameRevolution