Do you play as male or female Shepard? I think ultimately it comes down to a choice about voice actors. Sure, Mark Meer does a decent job, but Jennifer Hale is a pro. I wish I could say that for the rest of the voice-acting cast.
Freddy Prinze Jr.? Jessica Chobot? What the heck is this? And good God, Jessica Chobot's character model is ugly and holy shit does James Vega look like a total meat head or what? I'm sorry, but I have to be the one critical voice among the Mass Effect fanboys and fangirls (plural) here at GameRevolution.