Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood Review

danielrbischoff By:
danielrbischoff
11/16/10
GENRE Action / Adventure 
PLAYERS 1- 6 
PUBLISHER Ubisoft 
DEVELOPER Ubisoft 
RELEASE DATE  
M Contains Blood, Sexual Themes, Strong Language, Violence

What do these ratings mean?

Just when I thought I was out...


There's no denying that Assassin's Creed II was a massive improvement over the first game in the series. Among all of its amazing (and absolutely necessary) additions, the narrative stuck out as the most important progression Assassin's Creed could make. Sure it meandered here and there, and too many characters got involved too quickly to matter, but there was a point to killing all those people.

click to enlargeA year later and without a numerical value in its title, Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood sets out to prove itself, not unlike a young Ezio Auditore da Firenze. This time Ezio's grown himself a beard to last the whole game. His sister Claudia and his mother have met him in Rome as well, but more important are the few members of the Assassin's order you might care to remember. The Volpe and Machiavelli are by your side through Brotherhood's narrative, assisting you in rebuilding Rome one day at a time.

If you couldn't be bothered to refresh yourself on the ancient history that is Assassin's Creed II, you've got to be wondering how Ezio finds himself in Rome in the first place. Despite sparing the life of the previous installment's villain, Rodrigo Borgia, and reclaiming the all-powerful Apple of Eden, Ezio has not been forgiven by his enemies, who are all but content to let him rest at home in Monteriggioni. Rodrigo's general and son, Cesare, comes knocking and destroys the town you worked so hard to build in the second game. Of course, you're not going to let them get away with that, and if there is any hope of besting the Borgia at home in Rome, you're going to need back up.

Where AC II confined the economy and city-building aspects of Monteriggioni, Brotherhood blows it up to include the entirety of Rome. Throughout the city are Borgia towers, which house entire missions in and of themselves. Each tower has a leader who must be assassinated before you can scale the tower and set it ablaze, liberating the people of the area from Borgia influence. Once liberated, shops, transportation hubs, and banks can be renovated for the right price. These buildings generate revenue for the player and fuel the building mechanic throughout other areas of the city.

Easily the biggest and most entertaining addition to Brotherhood is the ability for the player to build your own guild of assassins. Heading to a pigeon coop or faction building will let you manage your assassins, and you can send them on missions, assign skill points, or even choose their colors. (Venetian wine is in this season, by the way.) The assassins you recruit are not relegated to contract orders, either. Using Brotherhood-assisted moves, you can call assassins to take out guards, lend a helping hand in open combat, or even launch a flurry of arrows at several guards.

click to enlargeEzio also has a crossbow that is more effective at taking enemies down from a distance and some new abilities that make open combat more user friendly. If you manage a successful counterattack, further executions can be strung along behind it. The same can be said of old-fashioned kills that come easier now that you can break your opponents guard with a kick. It's only been a year since the last game, but Ubisoft Montreal have taught an old dog some new tricks.

Aside from massive steps forward in terms of the open world being at your thumbs and much needed combat tweaks, Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood takes a huge leap forward in mission design. Areas encourage more stealthy play than all-out warfare, though missions remain varied enough to leave that style of play welcome. The first and second AC games left things too open, while Brotherhood offers several specific paths while still allowing you to make your own.

Even without a multiplayer mode, Assassin's Creed titles offer a ton of replayability in the story. Every mission includes a special constraint that makes things more difficult, and admittedly, more fun. Even killing Borgia captains around those damned towers have special parameters. The much marketed Leonardo missions are long, fanciful, involved affairs, but you'll want to go back to them right away to experience them all over again. Several VR training missions also challenge the player to obtain the highest possible score. These aren't the only nod to the Metal Gear games. Keep your eyes out when you meet up with Da Vinci again.

If you're wondering whether this game is just a multiplayer AC with a single-player expansion, you're wrong. Multiplayer doesn't hold back the story or gameplay of single player at all; in fact, I can't imagine an Assassin's Creed game releasing without multiplayer from now on. There is nothing more exhilarating than the constant, foreboding, nerve-racking cat-and-mouse game you'll play with others online. If it weren't for how unique and different multiplayer is, it probably wouldn't be as exciting, but it doesn't change the fact that Ubisoft Montreal made sure to churn out a fully-featured mode.

click to enlargeIn each mode, players earn points for their kills and the way they accomplish those kills. Aerial kills, acrobatic kills, silent and incognito kills all have specific point values and the ultimate goal is to score higher than everyone else. The Wanted game mode pits up to eight players against each other, with the highest-scoring player being chased by the others. Hunted pits one player as the assassin, one player as the victim, and the rest have to stop the killer. Alliance mode separates players into teams of two. As first outings go, Brotherhood's multiplayer mode delivers in spades.

Brotherhood's story is easier to follow, has an amazing variety of missions and replayability, and the soundtrack is amazing throughout. There's no doubt you'll be wanting more immediately following the end. With a campaign worthy of sequel status and a multiplayer mode full of fresh, entertaining ideas, there isn't enough praise I can lay on AC: Brotherhood. Assassin's Creed is one series I don't mind interacting with annually, monthly, daily, now.
A Revolution report card
  • Fully fledged story mode
  • Massive Rome full of things to do
  • Mission and gameplay variety
  • Building Rome in a day
  • VR missions, replaying story missions
  • Multiplayer is unique, breath of fresh air
  • Lots of multiplayer maps, modes, unlocks
More from the Game Revolution Network


  • Demosthenes
    Demosthenes - Joined: Aug 4, 2006
    So this is a perfect game?

    I swear, the quality of reviews on here has gone so far down the hill it's not funny. Two years ago it would have been nigh impossible for a game to get a review without any negative marks, let alone an A grade.

    This review is essentially you telling me what I can do in the game and how cool it is . . . well great, but I can get that from the trailers, I want you to give me an honest review on whether the game lived up to its premise and its promises and expectations, but I guess that's too much to ask . . .

    It's kinda sad when I can get a better review from Joystiq . . .
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 16th, 2010 at 6:57 pm
  • usaglory
    usaglory - Joined: Mar 14, 2009
    An A on GR? Well, I read the review at IGN before reading this one, and they make a pretty strong argument about some of the flaws in the game (like the use of the crossbow). I think if any one reviewer feels a game deserves that grade the whole GR crew should be in agreement before handing out the elusive and fabled A.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 16th, 2010 at 7:40 pm
  • RoadieTrash
    RoadieTrash - Joined: Jul 31, 2006
    If the multiplayer modes are really all they're cracked up to be, maaaaaaybe it'd be deserving of an A. That has got to be some sweet-ass multiplayer, though. He didn't give it an A+, don't go having an aneurysm just yet.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 16th, 2010 at 8:33 pm
  • danielrbischoff
    danielrbischoff - Joined: Nov 13, 2009
    @Demosthenes: How did I not inform you of whether the game lived up to its premise and its promises and expectations? How is that missing from this review?

    Here, I'll tell you now: It does. It is awesome.

    IGN also said the game was buggy. I saw no bugs at all in my retail Xbox 360 copy of the game.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 16th, 2010 at 10:29 pm
  • danielrbischoff
    danielrbischoff - Joined: Nov 13, 2009
    @usaglory: The GR staff does talk about the game before publishing an A. This is the first A I've ever handed out. GR has also given As to Red Dead Redemption and Halo: Reach this year. Whether or not you agree with those grades as well, AC: Brotherhood is definitely better than Halo: Reach (a game I have played intimately).
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 16th, 2010 at 10:30 pm
  • De-Ting
    De-Ting - Joined: Nov 11, 2006
    I expect the game is really good, but I'll have to play it to believe that grade.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 16th, 2010 at 10:49 pm
  • Demosthenes
    Demosthenes - Joined: Aug 4, 2006
    Because no game can possibly live up to all its hype. I can't find a single negative comment in your review, and that's your job, to find the negative and positive elements of a game and weight them against each other.

    I expect my games to have flaws and problems and things I don't like, it's a guarantee when I'm not the one designing it, NO game is perfect. Since I don't get a free copy to play as you do, I'm trusting you to tell me the Good and the Bad, so I can make an informed decision, you haven't done this.

    Please don't say there isn't any bad in this game, I'm not denying that it is a great game, Im getting it at midnight and I think I'll very much enjoy every part of it, however straight away I can see flaws and issues with the gameplay just from your overwhelmingly positive review and the others I've read. You can give it an A grade once you can tell me what its flaws are, and how they are overwhelmed by its more positive elements.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 1:36 am
  • Josh_Laddin
    Josh_Laddin - Joined: Nov 13, 2009
    @usaglory: An A is not "elusive and fabled." That's an A+, which no game has ever received in the history of the site. There have been quite a few A's over the years, though.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 3:05 am
  • the_mighty_toast
    the_mighty_toast - Joined: Jul 12, 2006
    I am sure that the entire staff at Game Revolution is completely disheartened that all their hard work seems to be worth nothing in the eyes of a higher power such as yourself, Demosthenes, but in reality your opinion is no more right than theirs. They gave the game an A, and told you why. If you do not agree, that's fine. Make your own review and post it. But degrading yourself by trying to scold the staff members only makes you look like a jackass.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 3:23 am
  • the_mighty_toast
    the_mighty_toast - Joined: Jul 12, 2006
    I am sure that the entire staff at Game Revolution is completely disheartened that all their hard work seems to be worth nothing in the eyes of a higher power such as yourself, Demosthenes, but in reality your opinion is no more right than theirs. They gave the game an A, and told you why. If you do not agree, that's fine. Make your own review and post it. But degrading yourself by trying to scold the staff members only makes you look like a jackass.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 3:25 am
  • Daddio
    Daddio - Joined: Nov 6, 2008
    Seriously, the biggest problem about GR now is the little ***** viewers who cry and cry about anything that happens. Think you can write a better review? THEN FUCKING WRITE IT! See the little part "Review by other members", well I don't see your name there. Cmon kid, post a review and watch everyone rip it apart.

    Holy hell IGN reviewed a game differently, **** son, I didn't know GR gave a SHIT about what other sites reviewed games as. OMG it was Daniel who posted the 'A', bet if it was any other reviewer you wouldn't say **** to em. It's obvious that before posting this review it was passed around the staff and made sure that it deserved such a high score.

    Also, check out the review section and view all the games reviewed on the site, make it so the highest rating is listed at the top and be AMAZED at how many A's have been handed out to GOOD games in the past 2 years.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 4:48 am
  • truncheon5000
    truncheon5000 - Joined: Jul 22, 2009
    I have to play 1 & 2 first. I still have AC2 in it's packaging, I refuse to open it till I finish the first one. Might be an Assassins Creed marathon this weekend now, 123 BAM
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 6:26 am
  • usaglory
    usaglory - Joined: Mar 14, 2009
    @Josh_Laddin: you sir, are correct. My bad. As for A+'s, I wouldn't have it any other way.
    As for ACB, considering other things I've read I still think an A- would be more appropiate, then again it's a matter of opinion after all and danielrbischoff HAS played the game while I've only read about it. So there.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 6:48 am
  • strangebiscuit
    strangebiscuit - Joined: Apr 2, 2008
    Demosthenes = πουτσοκέφαλος

    Drink the poison already.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 7:48 am
  • mrallamericanboy
    mrallamericanboy - Joined: Jun 19, 2006
    I'm buying it. GR has never led me astray.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 7:50 am
  • wildmario
    wildmario - Joined: Jan 17, 2007
    Demon, if all you want is to find people pissing and moaning about a game's flaws, go watch Zero Punctuation. Everyone loves a whiner there.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 8:58 am
  • UghRochester
    UghRochester - Joined: Jun 5, 2006
    I feel the reason why Daniel gave it an "A" was the new multi-playing thrill added to the game. I'm sure he will agree with me on this point.

    Also I can see Demon's point (very blurry I will say). Video game reviews that get so much positive feedback and not given any negative flaws, are usually works of a fanboy. While giving all negative feedback about a game is usually someone that never played the game. I don't think Daniel is a fanboy for AC, but I do think he didn't focus that much on the negative aspects.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 9:25 am
  • daverabbit
    daverabbit - Joined: Oct 2, 2008
    The end point of any review I read is whether or not i should spend my hard earned money on it. This review clearly tells me that i should spend my hard earned money on Assassins Creed Brotherhood. I don't really need to know much more then that. And much like mrallamericanboy said, GR has never led me astray.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 11:24 am
  • MrrClean
    MrrClean - Joined: Aug 7, 2010
    I havent even read this review yet, just all the blogging and *****ing that has followed. Everyone here has made some pretty good points. It does seem like higher grades were harder to achive before, but perhaps that was because the gaming industry wasn't what it is now. Keep in mind, vthe games industry is worth more than Hollywood right now, its getting a lot more attention than it used to. Just a thought.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 1:06 pm
  • MrrClean
    MrrClean - Joined: Aug 7, 2010
    Another thought... While I'm sure this game is going to be totally awesome, and deserving of an excellent grade, I can think of one thing that, in my books anyway, would drop it down to an A-... its really just another Assasins Creed game. You're gonna run around well made, HD old citys and kill guys in well done, amusing brutal ways, fly through the skys, jump off of huge buildings and somehow survive... but you could do all that in the first one. And the second one. Don't get me wrong, I played the living sh*t out of AC2, I loved it. But I dunno... New, original ideas are something that I fear are going to be crushed under the huge potential profits of established franchises (Halo, CoD, Assasins Creed, etc.). Just my two cents.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 1:06 pm
  • Demosthenes
    Demosthenes - Joined: Aug 4, 2006
    @Daddio Sure I could right a review, but the difference is I have to pay for the game. The lovely staff here at GR get paid to play these games and tell us about them, so I think it's fair to request a balanced review. Also it has nothing to do with the fact that Daniel in particular wrote it, nor what other sites are saying, I give no weight to IGNs reviews.

    @Wildmario I don't want him to moan about the games flaws, I want him to consider them and balance them against all the positives in the game. There is a difference.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 2:05 pm
  • danielrbischoff
    danielrbischoff - Joined: Nov 13, 2009
    I have to be honest: I would much rather comments on my reviews be of a challenging nature than those of IGN or Gametrailers where the initialcomments are "first" and other pee-brained fueled feedback.

    I stand by my review (my opinion) of Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood. If you want good measured against bad, you can take away the fact that there is an overwhelming amount of good in this particular title. I didn't hand out an A lightly. I'll never do that. I am not ungrateful for my position and I take my responsibilty to you readers seriously.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 3:45 pm
  • danielrbischoff
    danielrbischoff - Joined: Nov 13, 2009
    Other reviews have some negatives... They were not present in my 30+ hours with the game. Had the multiplayer not been as good, had I experienced glitches or other troublesome nuances, they would have been noted.

    I am not an AC fanboy. I had a particularly negative outlook on this title from it's announcement. I thought it was a cash-in, a wasted multiplayer effort. I put this game through it's paces. I still walked away extremely satisfied. The A stands.

    And no, I don't give a **** what IGN or Gamespot or any other reviewers think. This is what I think. 
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 3:47 pm
  • usaglory
    usaglory - Joined: Mar 14, 2009
    Points duly noted. Look, in my case, I didn't mean to offend or piss-off anyone. I apologize if I came across that way.
    However, my point is that you have to have found something not entirely to your satisfaction within the game, even if in a nit-picky way. Maybe an ugly texture here and there or a frame rate dip somewhere, I mean something to have given it an A, but it is not mentioned. Or to put it differently, what kept you from giving the game an A+ then?
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 4:13 pm
  • Demosthenes
    Demosthenes - Joined: Aug 4, 2006
    "I stand by my review (my opinion) of Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood" I think this is what I'm taking issue with. The fact that the whole review is your opinion and preferences. Now don't get me wrong, I want your personality and preferences to be evident in the review, but I also want a balanced consideration of the game from a broader perspective.
    Take the Apprentice assassins mechanic. From all accounts you approve entirely, however, there are others, who view this a cheap and easy way to kill someone with the click of a button and next to no effort. I don't intend to make use of this particular tool in the game. Is it a glitch? No, but it's a possible flaw too some portion of the people who will buy the game, and had I been you (and everyone reading this now gives thanks that Im not) I would have made this a +/- feature of the game.
    I hope that gives you a better idea of what I mean by discussing flaws or possible negatives in the game.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 5:29 pm
  • MrrClean
    MrrClean - Joined: Aug 7, 2010
    @Demosthenes: "The fact that the whole review is your opinion and preferences..."

    Well, what the f*ck else do you think its gonna be? A review by any individual is going to be influenced by that persons opinions and preferences.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 9:31 pm
  • Green_Lantern
    Green_Lantern - Joined: Nov 6, 2008
    God I love review trolls.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 17th, 2010 at 9:47 pm
  • Demosthenes
    Demosthenes - Joined: Aug 4, 2006
    @MrrClean Thanks for not reading and understanding my post before criticising. Believe it or not, it is possible to consider what other people may find to be good or bad about a game outside of your own personal preferences. And I do believe with all my heart that Daniel is more than capable of doing that as a writer. He simply hasn't in this article. I don't mind if its influenced by his opinions, it should be, what I don't like is that there's nothing else in the review except that.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 18th, 2010 at 1:02 am
  • KingKems
    KingKems - Joined: Aug 3, 2010
    @Demosthenes
    "I expect my games to have flaws and problems and things I don't like, it's a guarantee when I'm not the one designing it, NO game is perfect"

    So if you ARE the one designing it, it would be a perfect game? You're so full of yourself, and so caught up with this review. How about you just chill out, go buy the game, and then start disagreeing with Daniel after you have some evidence to back up your argument?

    And aside from that, there's no reason to be condescending, especially to someone who is part of a prestigious and long-standing game association/website.

    Get outta your mom's basement, man.

    @Daniel: I can't wait to play. =)
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 18th, 2010 at 2:57 pm
  • KingKems
    KingKems - Joined: Aug 3, 2010
    @Demosthenes
    "I expect my games to have flaws and problems and things I don't like, it's a guarantee when I'm not the one designing it, NO game is perfect"

    So if you ARE the one designing it, it would be a perfect game? You're so full of yourself, and so caught up with this review. How about you just chill out, go buy the game, and then start disagreeing with Daniel after you have some evidence to back up your argument?

    And aside from that, there's no reason to be condescending, especially to someone who is part of a prestigious and long-standing game association/website.

    Get outta your mom's basement, man.

    @Daniel: I can't wait to play. =)
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 18th, 2010 at 3:01 pm
  • acdibble
    acdibble - Joined: Jul 11, 2007
    It's just Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood, not Assassin's Creed II: Brotherhood.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 18th, 2010 at 4:38 pm
  • danielrbischoff
    danielrbischoff - Joined: Nov 13, 2009
    @acdibble: I know... I'm going to try to fix it when I'm in the office tomorrow.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 18th, 2010 at 6:00 pm
  • watsonovedades
    watsonovedades - Joined: Nov 28, 2010
    not Assassin's Creed II: Brotherhood.
    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Nov 28th, 2010 at 4:25 am
  • shyne
    shyne - Joined: Feb 3, 2011
    Man I love this game!


    0 0Like or Dislike?
    Posted: Feb 7th, 2011 at 5:12 am

Post a Comment
LOGIN or REGISTER to post a comment or rate this article.

Click here for another Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood review
 


More information about Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood
Also known as: Assassin's Creed Brotherhood, Assassins Creed Brotherhood, Assassin's Creed II: Brotherhood Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood