More Reviews
REVIEWS Ultra Street Fighter II: The Fin Review
Dip, but don't double dip.

Disgaea 5 Complete Review
Tactical devastation made portable.
More Previews
PREVIEWS Let It Die Preview
Seems like Suda51 saw Frozen, played Dark Souls, and then got the lyrics mixed up.
Release Dates
Release date: Out Now

Utawarerumono Mask of Deception
Release date: Out Now

The Elder Scrolls Online: Morrowind
Release date: 06/06/17

MotoGP 17
Release date: 06/15/17

Read More Member Blogs
Welcome Back to the West
By oneshotstop
Posted on 08/01/16
The only thing that stops the dust is the rain. It’s a sweet reprieve, but there is no middle ground. The land is either as dry as the Betty Ford clinic, or as wet as the ocean floor. Everything can be seen from the ridge overlooking Armadillo as John Marston gently bounces along atop...

Sherlock Holmes vs. Jack the Ripper Review

KevinS By:
GENRE Adventure 
PUBLISHER Focus Home Interactive 
DEVELOPER Frogwares Studio 
T Contains Mild Blood, Mild Language, Sexual Themes, Use of Alcohol and Tobacco, Violence

What do these ratings mean?

Elementary... school?

Sherlock Holmes vs. Jack the Ripper is a classic, exploration-based mystery title. When you think about it, that in and of itself should be what steers you away; there's a reason this genre started its sad and sharp demise over the past decade. If you've played one, that doesn't mean you've played them all... but very likely, it means you've played a better one than this.

click to enlargeYou take on the dual role of Sherlock Holmes and Doctor Watson in a batch of grisly, gruesome murders that begin in the slums of London. Because of the title, we know they're the work of Jack the Ripper (sorry, if I've ruined the magic for everyone), but the trick here is to discover who Jack the Ripper really is. As Holmes and Watson - the story branches off to let a player take the reins of both men - you slog through the soiled streets filled with dirty child workers, wandering drunks, homeless drunks, and the occasional (and by “occasional”, I mean “the streets are filled with them”) “ladies of the evening”. Also known, to you and me, as hookers.

Which actually brings me to the first notable problem with this game... too many hookers. (I never knew it could be a problem.) Seriously, they're everywhere, and they're just so... creepy. I've never seen a prostitute in a game (or in real life, for that matter) who struck me as something out of a zombie movie, but here they're all filthy and give the impression of walking death. When you get in close, they're all covered in sores and what I hope is mud. The lady in charge of the brothel (yup, the head-honcho of the brigade) even talks to Watson about how some of her girls are infected with syphilis. It's so gross that I sped through the dialog to hear about how the murders took place.

Morbid = interesting, prostitutes with VD = disgusting and unnecessary *shudder*.

Back to the ruthless killings: Your task as the detective is to look over all of the evidence given to the “unstumpable” Holmes to piece together what happened to the poor women killed throughout the murdering spree. New evidence will turn up from time to time, and with it, another trip to the deduction board. This game prides itself on logic, and while occasionally the most basic of logic will help you to navigate the various puzzles – for example, moving around a magnet to pull a hook from under a glass table without touching the sides a-la the board game Operation – there will be a spot where yanking out a hair or two would be just as productive.

click to enlargeAnd yet, the actual deductions are, by comparison, cake. When the logic doesn't seem to be making much sense, just start punching in different combinations until you find the right one... and it'll tell you when it's right, because the final conclusion turns green. There aren't that many combinations, as there are only a few options as to what a piece of info might mean. Trial and error stumps stupidity.

Visually, it's on the level of an original Xbox game like Indigo Prophecy. Even though it came out on the PC first a while ago, that doesn't excuse the fact that it looks downright outdated. The towns look fine enough and filled with what looks like authentic detail, but the people all kind of remind me of the G-Man from Half-Life... and that includes the prostitutes (ooohhhh, those prostitutes).

Of the people just meandering around the city, there are only a handful of different faces to see, and when you decide to speak to them you'll only hear a handful of different expressions. It gives the impression that the developers just didn't finish. Colors might be sometimes different from person to person, but it's disheartening to see so many sets of twins walking around. Sometimes they're even right next to each other, in the same clothes, with the same spots and dirt smeared on them.

The dialog and conversations between characters is bland and awkward, complete with some bad overacting and funky-fake British accents (think “worse than Mr. Wick from The Drew Carey Show” bad). If it had any real humor in it, it could almost work. But the only part that's “funny” in this serious story is that you have to swarm a fat lady with cats. Still, even that is just ho-hum to watch... just a fat lady squirming with some stationary kitties draped around her.

click to enlargeThe conversations and exploration are what this whole shebang is based on, so it's a big letdown at how utterly boring the speech is. Even Watson and Holmes are as basic as can be. When your most interesting character, the first name on the box, only has the “I know everything and everyone else is there to be manipulated/outsmarted/an idiot” attitude (even to Watson), it's hard for a player to care about whatever it is he's doing.

Wow... I must sound like a real jerk to anyone who loves this genre at all (the few of you left). If you want a detective story that's told in an interesting and thoughtful fashion, there's always Phoenix Wright and Sam & Max. The folks on Baker Street just ain't what it used to be.
D Revolution report card
  • Detailed areas to wander through
  • Some intriguing puzzles scattered throughout
  • ...but some are way too simple and frustrating
  • Awful voice-acting
  • Way too many creepy hookers
    Reviews by other members
    No member reviews for the game.

comments powered by Disqus

More information about Sherlock Holmes vs. Jack the Ripper
Also known as: Sherlock Holmes versus Jack The Ripper

More On GameRevolution