It's not a game; it's an obsession!
So brazenly declares the box cover of Battle Tactics
, the new add-on
pack for cavedog's real-time-strategy-game, Total Annihilation. Pity, that's
just the problem. Total Annihilation
is very good and
there are plenty of people for whom the game has become an obsession. It also
has made Cavedog a truckload of greenbacks and they seem to think that since
the game is so damn popular, that they can throw anything linked to it on the
market and score a quick cash infusion.
is a quick, basic, uninspired add-on pack that consists
of nothing more than 100 new maps slightly geared to cultivate specific play
skills, 6 new skirmish maps, and 4 new bland units. That's all, no new story,
no new terrain types, no new factions or races to throw to the mix, nothing.
You'd think that after the original Total Annihilation
and the expansion pack The Core Contingency
that Cavedog would give us
something more in an add on. Core Contingency
gave us 75 new units, 25
new story-linked maps, and 6 new terrain sets, making Battle Tactics
look even more depressingly anemic. The basic premise of Battle Tactics, which
raises it slightly above shovelware, is that the maps are designed to train
the player in advanced Total Annihilation
Each side, Core and Arm, are given 4 new campaigns: very short, short, medium,
and large maps. The small maps are there to teach you one very specific skill
(Also, for all the maps, there is a little "Tactics" section is the Scenario
box). Then as the maps get larger more complex combinations of skills are necessary.
For instance, in a small map you might learn how to use the D-Gun effectively
and in a larger map you have to be able to carry out a D-Day invasion effectively...
in theory. In practice, I found that for the most part Battle Tactics was just
100 badly designed maps, sometimes with interesting enemy placements. Rarely
would a map give you any real options as to how to beat it, leaving you only
with the skill of how to beat that map, but not how to kick ass and take names
in an all important net game.
To add to the banality of it all, almost all of the battles take place on
basic flat landscapes with the occasional landmark, nothing interesting though.
They all feel like skirmish maps. Also, several of these training scenarios
For example, there was one map in which the task was to take out a well-fortified
enemy compound with a pre-determined force and only 25 minutes to do it in.
En fin (that's French for 'In the end' for all you uncultured swine), it turned
out that all I had to do to win was to select all of my very large army and
blitzkrieg the enemy base.
element of Battle Tactics that makes it non-recommendable is its area of appeal.
A training package would theoretically appeal to TA players who aren't good
and want to better their skills. However, these players probably wouldn't care
enough about TA to want to shell out cash for Battle Tactics
. On the
flip, Battle Tactics
would seem to appeal to the more advanced players
who want to hone their skills. But, since Battle Tactics
teach any useful net skills (which can only truly be learned in a net game),
it doesn't really appeal to the good players either. Having beaten the single
player game, they mostly just play on the net.
Also, it's a little too hard for players who suck at TA. So what you're still
left with is 100 uninteresting maps (save a few), 4 new units that wont leave
you singing hosanna, and 6 new skirmish maps no better than the ones that came
with the original game.
The only people who might want to buy this are those who don't have net access
(and therefore aren't reading this) and can't download the many good new units
and maps available on the good 'ol corny World Wide Web (I shudder to say it).
Also, the one-time install of Battle Tactics
takes up a not-too-easy-to-live-with-and-possibly-intolerable
180 megabytes of hard drive space.
It seems that Battle Tactics
is the product of Cavedog being massively
full of themselves after their success with TA and the fact that everyone with
any talent at Cavedog is working on the Total Annihilation sequels (Kingdoms
and TA 2). It is an uninspired scar on the TA name that we'd all do a lot better