More Reviews
REVIEWS Dark Souls II: Crown of the Sunk Review
I was confident in my Dark Souls abilities. Then From Software released new Dark Souls II DLC.

The Swapper Review
One of 2013's best indie games swaps its way to Sony platforms.
More Previews
PREVIEWS Pillars of Eternity Preview
For Obsidian's crowdfunded love letter to Infinity Engine games like Icewind Dale and Baldur's Gate, I was impressed by its willingness to pull back the curtain and let me see the machinery behind it.
Release Dates
NEW RELEASES Sacred 3
Release date: 08/05/14

CounterSpy
Release date: 08/19/14

Tales of Xillia 2
Release date: 08/19/14

Plants Vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare
Release date: 08/19/14


LATEST FEATURES Forging the Rings of Power in Middle Earth: Shadow of Mordor
Tolkien fans may now either squeal with glee at getting to play interactive fanfiction... or condemn it to the watery grave of Numenor.

How Bioware Creates Romances
Bioware's games have romances where you might save the world, on the side of course.
MOST POPULAR FEATURES Picking Your Gender: 5 Industry Professionals Discuss Queer Identity in Gaming
Women from Naughty Dog, ArenaNet, Harmonix, and Gamespot unite to talk about what they want from games in terms of diversity.
 
Coming Soon

LEADERBOARD
Read More Member Blogs
FEATURED VOXPOP Kakulukia
Why Sunset Overdrive Can Go Suck A Lemon
By Kakulukia
Posted on 07/14/14
Yesterday, while cleaning up my media center, I found my copy of Ratchet & Clank: Into The Nexus, which I bought sometime before Christmas last year. I had been pretty excited about this game pre-release, what with it being the first "traditional", albeit shorter than usual,...

Top Spin 3 Review

Nick_Tan By:
Nick_Tan
07/28/08
PRINTER FRIENDLY VERSION
EMAIL TO A FRIEND
GENRE Sports 
PLAYERS 1- 4 
PUBLISHER 2K Sports 
DEVELOPER 2K Sports 
RELEASE DATE  
E Contains No Descriptors

What do these ratings mean?

A safe forehand winner.

Would it be strange if I told you that your fellow RPG-loving, rhythm-thumping reviewer also follows tennis? I’m not hardcore or anything, but enough so that I was floored when Rafael Nadal ended Roger Federer’s five-year reign as the king of Wimbledon in an epic match that went into a 9-7 fifth-set and hailed as one of the best finals ever. It was jam-packed with unbelievable slices, crowd-gasping mistakes, aggressive near- or on-the-line winners, and just plain ridiculous shots from ridiculous angles with ridiculous precision. Fans who began the match rooting for their favorites ended up roaring, cheering, and gasping over every point because they are getting their money’s worth.

click to enlargeTop Spin 3 tries to serve up an experience as close to that as possible by putting a realistic spin on the usual pick-up-and-play approach on tennis, or what I like to call "Life-sized Pong". Like the Virtua Tennis series, it forces players to pay attention to the timing of the swing, the placement of the ball, and the variety of shots without getting so overly technical that it bogs down the action. Its no-fills, no-nonsense style safely fits within its simulation scheme. However, it doesn’t capture the spirit of tennis as thoroughly as it could have.

If there’s one thing that Top Spin 3 nails dead-on, it’s the mechanics of the fundamental part of tennis: the swing. Holding down different buttons and different directions on the analog stick performs various shots like slices, drop shots, and lobs. How long you hold the button before you release determines the shot’s power, and the direction you point the analog stick as you swing determines the shot’s angle.

This scheme reinforces the idea that you have to get behind the ball and, most importantly, to watch your timing, especially if you want any chance in online matches. When you have to release the racket actually depends on your character’s swing animation as it follows through the ball, and since forehands, backhands, lobs, and drop shots all have different animations, getting the ball over the net consistently takes a lot of practice and concentration. Any stumble in your placement sends you tripping over your feet, and any stumble in your timing lands the ball right into the net or someplace far, far away.

Of course, that would be too simple. If you want to compete with the best of the best, you need to use risky shots, which are executed by holding the trigger buttons down while you swing. You have a choice of either knocking a winner near the line or executing a Miss Sharapova power shot that whizzes past even the fastest sprinters, or a shot that does both. The riskier the shot, however, the more precise your timing has to be, and even after hours of practice in the Top Spin School, the success rate may not improve by much. As such, only those with hawk eyes should think about engaging in any online tournaments. Even my character, a six-foot-nine giant with a 100-max stat in power, who can rip any ball cross-court like nobody’s business, doesn’t stand a chance against a player that can wield risky shots.

click to enlargeThankfully, players who are having trouble can turn the difficulty down a few notches to have a more straightforward tennis match and still have a satisfying ball-thwacking bout. Hit-and-volley opponents will still frustrate you if you’re a baseliner, and it’s always amusing, with an evil smirk kind, to force your opponents on a heaving gallop from one side of the court to the other.

Just watching the players move and the environments change is enough to make anyone want to pick up the controller. Player animations are fluid and seamless, without a single hitch or jerk. In particular, Andy Roddick’s stinging, un-telegraphed serve is virtually perfect. As players drain their stamina as the match gets longer and longer, their faces and the armpits of their clothes become drenched in sweat. Shadows creep across the court as the sun slides across the sky, all the more to make you believe that you’re in a living, breathing world.

The mood is expectedly serious and stoic, highlighted by an arduous career mode that slugs you through the amateur and junior ranks, and pits you into three-round events on clay, grass, and hard court as well as the longer, more prestigious Grand Slam tournaments such as the Australian Open and the French Open. Your life-like character is fully customizable from head to toe, via a character creation tool that can even professionally tweak a player’s face with a point transformation system. Moreover, you can purchase tennis clothes and equipment through a mock outlet mall, though having three floors of stores is rather pointless when you can access a global shop that has every purchasable item in stock.

Unfortunately, Top Spin 3 fails to capture the aural atmosphere of tennis. Crowds usually only muster a stilted applause and a few ‘yahoos’ and ‘yeahs’. Even if you’re playing in the finals of the Australian Open, the crowd doesn’t do anything but clap like they’re watching an off-off-Broadway show in Tunisia. Real-life audiences cheer if you represent their country or become heavy with anticipation if you’re in a match with a Top 10 ranked player, but none of that happens here. And as far as how the crowd looks, it’s like a throng of dim-witted Sims 2 characters showed up just to see what they should like in next-gen.

click to enlargeOn top of that, there’s no trophy ceremony, no celebration of any kind, just a bunch of stilted animated sequences that hardly changes, no matter whether you won your fifth career Grand Slam or a match against a paraplegic. There’s also no variation in the chair empire’s voice, which after two hours starts to sound as monotonous as an announcement by your middle-school principal. So by the time you reach the French Open, you’ll actually be relieved to hear some French.

Players who are into the number-crunching of stat-tracking will be slighted. Only the most basic of statistics are available like a percentage of how you won or lost points. A breakdown how many points you win or lose on a specific court surface, with a specific shot, or against specific players are unavailable.

You can’t even access your opponent’s attributes like power, speed, and stamina, apart from a short loading screen of your opponent’s attributes right before a match begins. On that note, you can’t even max out your character’s attributes, which is restricted to an overall rating of 70, when many of your opponents have overall ratings higher than that. It’s just a poor way to force the game to remain challenging and fair, when all that’s needed to create balance is to have opponents with overall stats in the 90s.

click to enlargeBut worst of all, Rafael Nadal is all but missing. (I’m sure Federer is happy to hear that.) The last three to five years of men’s tennis have more or less been dominated by the Nadal vs. Federer rivalry, so not having Rafa around is inexcusable. Fans of women’s tennis will also be put off by the absence of the Williams sisters. Sure you could create those characters, but without their official representation, you can’t compete against them in career matches or any matches that actually matter. Oh, and where is Wimbledon?

Top Spin 3 latches onto back-to-basics tennis, focusing its full attention on the play, power, and flow of the sport. The result is fairly straightforward but strong enough for anyone to pick up and appreciate the sport for what it is. The quibbles with the attribute cap and the lack of crowd interaction are fairly minimal. However, those hoping to recreate the infamous Federer vs. Nadal final or the Serena vs. Venus Williams final at the 2008 Wimbledon will have to look elsewhere.

B Revolution report card
  • Tennis in its most fundamental form
  • Solid swing mechanics
  • Realistic graphics and fluid animations
  • Approachable by anyone
  • Lackluster audience
  • Attribute cap
  • Incomplete character roster
  • Where\'s Wimbledon?
More from the Game Revolution Network




comments powered by Disqus

 


More information about Top Spin 3


More On GameRevolution