Tell GR | Do you read reviews before buying games?

Death Stranding reviews made their way online last week, and the internet has got itself all worked up about some of the wildly different scores that have been published. We gave it a 5 out of 5 in our own review, though Hideo Kojima’s latest certainly isn’t for everyone, and many will no doubt benefit from reading critics’ thoughts on it before they buy.

But we want to hear your thoughts on whether or not reviews impact your buying habits. Do you scour the internet for reviews before picking up a new release, or do you generally overlook the critical consensus? Let us know in the comments section below, and we’ll feature our favorite response in tomorrow’s Tell GR!

Death Stranding Mads Mikkelsen Cliff

Paul Tamburro, executive editor: “I do, though rarely will a review sway my decision on whether or not I’ll buy it. Given that I spend every day covering and reading about the games industry, I usually have a solid handle on whether a game will appeal to me before I buy it. I’ll always read different perspectives from the critics I enjoy, but my interest is typically locked in before the reviews roll around.”

Jason Faulkner, senior editor: “I only give GameRevolution reviews any salt. Most of the time, I’ll just ask one of the guys here if they’ve played it, or watch gameplay on YouTube. Sometimes, if an older game catches my eye, I might look it up on Metacritic. For the most part, if a game piques my interest I’ll just go in blind and hope for the best.”

Mack Ashworth, lead editor: “Unless they’re for a game whose story I really don’t want spoiling, which is rare, I’ll read a bunch of reviews before making a purchase. With so many games out there to play, I don’t really have the time to waste tens of hours on a subpar title. Reviews help me lower the priority on those games.”

Michael Leri, features editor: “I only read reviews pre-release if I truly don’t know what to think about a game, which does not happen often. Generally, if I know I’m going to play it, I’ll just read reviews after I finish said title. I like to avoid spoilers at all costs so that is why I use reviews more like critical reading pieces over buying advice. But Death Stranding is throwing all of this out the window.”

Loksoral wins last week’s best Tell GR reply!

Question: “What’s the scariest moment you’ve faced in a game?”

“Condemned 2, and that fucking bear scene.

Fuck that scene.”

Upcoming Releases

Tactical, beautiful, and wholly unique, the GOTY-winning sci-fi RTS returns with Homeworld 3. Assume control and battle through fleet combat in dazzling, fully 3D space while the award-winning story unfolds on a galactic scale.
The sequel to the award winning Hellblade: Senua’s Sacrifice, Senua returns in a brutal journey of survival through the myth and torment of Viking Iceland. Intent on saving those who have fallen victim to the horrors of tyranny, Senua faces a battle of overcoming the darkness within and without.
Inspired by the beauty of the natural world around us, Everwild is a brand-new game in development from Rare where unique and unforgettable experiences await in a natural and magical world. Play as an Eternal as you explore and build bonds with the world around you.

Reviews