Box art - Animal Crossing: New Horizons

Animal Crossing: New Horizons ‘One Thing to a Deserted Island’ | What should I choose?

If you’re struggling with the question right at the start of the game, this Animal Crossing: New Horizons one thing to a deserted island guide will let you know how to answer the question you’re struggling with. Read on to discover how to answer the ‘if you could only bring one thing with you to a deserted island, what would it be?’ question in Animal Crossing: New Horizons. Find out what answer you should choose below.

Animal Crossing: New Horizons ‘One Thing to a Deserted Island’ | What should I choose?

Animal Crossing: New Horizons One Thing to a Deserted Island

While there aren’t too many difficult moments in Animal Crossing: New Horizons, one of the opening questions at the start of the game might leave you scratching your head. Timmy and Tommy Nook will ask you this question: “If you could only bring one thing with you to a deserted island, what would it be?” Upon asking this question, the Nook twins give you four options, which you can see below.

ALSO: GDC Summer replacing postponed show, coming in August

The four Animal Crossing: New Horizons “one thing to a deserted island choices” are as follows (as you can see in the image above:

  • A sleeping bag
  • A lamp
  • Some food
  • Something to kill time

Don’t be nervous about answering this question. It doesn’t matter what you choose here. You can choose any of the four responses and you will receive all four items upon your arrival to the deserted island anyway. After making your choice, Timmy Nook will tell you that it was just a hypothetical question. Your choice here doesn’t affect anything, as far as we’re aware. You’ll get all four items as soon as you arrive.

Pick any of the four options listed above when you’re asked the question. It doesn’t matter one bit what you choose and the whole thing could be there just to mess with you, given that some of the other questions do change things for you.