You’ll want to know how Abigail will react to gifts in Stardew Valley if you’re trying to befriend or marry her. It can be tough to guess what gifts Abigail loves as it’s a relatively eclectic collection of items. Fortunately, we’ve got the complete list of Abigail’s loved, liked, neutral, disliked, and hated gifts below, so you don’t have to go through the trial and error of finding out what to give her.
Stardew Valley Abigail Loved Gifts
Loved gifts will give you 80 relationship points (aside from Stardrop Tea, which offers 250).
When Abigail receives a loved gift in Stardew Valley, she says, “I seriously love this! You’re the best (Character Name)!”
All Universal Loves:
- Golden Pumpkin
- Magic Rock Candy
- Pearl
- Prismastic Shard
- Rabbit’s Foot
- Stardrop Tea
Personal Loved Gifts:
- Amethyst
- Banana Pudding
- Blackberry Cobbler
- Chocolate Cake
- Monster Compendium
- Pufferfish
- Pumpkin
- Spicy Eel
Abigail Liked Gifts
Liked Gifts give 45 relationship points.
If you give Abigail a liked gift, she’ll say: “Hey, how’d you know I was hungry? This looks delicious!”
For some reason, Abigail will say the above line regardless of whether you’re giving her food or not.
All Universal Likes (Except for vegetables):
- Artisan Goods (Except for Oil and Void Mayonnaise)
- Cooked Goods (Except for Bread, Fried Egg, Seafoam Pudding, and Strange Bun)
- Flowers (Except for Poppy)
- Forged Minerals
- Fruit Tree Fruits (Except for Banana and Mango)
- Gems (Except for Prismatic Shard)
- Life Elixir
- Maple Syrup
- Pina Colada
- Rainbow Shell
- Treasure Chest
Personal Liked Gifts:
- Ancient Sword
- Basilisk Paw
- Bone Flute
- Combat Quarterly
- Quartz
Abigail Neutral Gifts:
You’ll get 20 relationship points from neutral gifts.
Giving Abigail a neutral gift will get the response, “You brought me a present? Thanks.”
All Universal Neutrals (Except Combat Quarterly and Monster Compendium):
- All Books (Except Price Catalogue)
- Bread
- Coral
- Duck Feather
- Fried Egg
- Hops
- Nautilus Shell
- Roe
- Squid Ink
- Sweet Gem Berry
- Tea Leaves
- Truffle
- Wheat
- Wool
Personal Neutral Gifts:
- All Milks
- Chanterelle
- Common Mushroom
- Daffodil
- Dandelion
- Ginger
- Hazelnut
- Leek
- Magma Cap
- Morel
- Purple Mushroom
- Snow Yam
- Winter Root
Abigail Disliked Gifts
Giving Abigail a disliked gift will decrease your relationship by 25 points.
If Abigail dislikes a gift, she’ll say: “What am I supposed to do with this?”
All Universal Dislikes (Except Ancient Sword, Basilisk Paw, Bone Flute, Clay, and Pufferfish):
- All Building Materials
- All Artifacts
- All Bombs
- All Crafted Floors and Paths
- All Fences
- All Fertilizer
- All Fish (Except Carp and Snails)
- All Geode Minerals
- All Geodes
- All Seeds
- All Sprinklers
- All Tackle
- All Trinkets
- Bone Fragment
- Cave Carrot
- Cinder Shard
- Coal
- Copper Bars
- Driftwood
- Field Snack
- Gold Bars
- Gold Ore
- Iridium Ore
- Iron Bars
- Jack-O-Lantern
- Oak Resin
- Oil
- Pine Tar
- Price Catalogue
- Qi Fruit
- Refined Quartz
- Rice
- Solar Essence
- Spring Onion
- Tea Set
- Unmilled Rice
- Vinegar
- Void Egg
- Void Essence
- Wheat Flour
Personal Disliked Gifts:
- All Eggs
- All Fruit
- All Vegetables (except Hops, Pumpkin, Tea Leaves, and Wheat)
- Sugar
- Horseradish
Abagail Hated Gifts
Giving Abigail a hated gift will decrease your relationship by 40 points.
If Abigail hates your gift, she’ll say: “What were you thinking? This is awful!”
All Universal Hates (Except Sugar):
- All Baits
- All Fossils
- All Monster Loot
- All Trash
- Artifact Trove
- Bug Steak
- Butterfly Powder
- Carp
- Copper Ore
- Crab Pot
- Dragon Tooth
- Drum Block
- Energy Tonic
- Error Item
- Explosive Ammo
- Fairy Dust
- Flute Block
- Grass Starter
- Green Algae
- Golden Coconut
- Hay
- Iron Ore
- Journal Scrap
- Monster Musk
- Muscle Remedy
- Oil of Garlic
- Poppy
- Qi Seasoning
- Radioactive Bar
- Radioactive Ore
- Rain Totem
- Red Mushroom
- Sap
- Sea Urchin
- Seafoam Pudding
- Seaweed
- Secret Note
- Slime Egg
- Snail
- Strange Bun
- Torch
- Voice Mayonnaise
- Warp Totem (Any)
- White Algae
Personal Hated Gifts:
- Clay
- Holly
