“Pay Whatever You Want” Model Is Not Successful, Says Indie Developer

Having only sold his game on his website, Joost "Oogst" Van Paren, the indie developer behind the critically successful Proun, was not under any contractual obligation to conceal the financial success of the game's "Pay What You Want" model. But as much as the game was downloaded an incredible amount of times, he's thoroughly disappointed by the results:

But didn't I make a lot of money with Proun? More than ten thousand euros, isn't that a lot of money? Yes and no. To me personally, Proun did incredibly well. That is a lot of money to make with a side-project, and since I get to keep most of it myself… wow!

However, over 250,000 people played Proun… Through Ronimo and through my connections to indie developers all over the world, I know what kind of money a game that achieves that kind of success can make. If I would not have done the Pay What You Want model and would have done a fixed price on Steam instead, I think I may have made 5 to 10 times as much money. That is while even taking into consideration that without the Pay What You Want model, the game would have generated a lot less buzz and much fewer people would have played it.

While the Pay What You Want model is a "tremendous marketing tool", it resulted in only "1.76% of the players" paying for Proun. One of the main reasons is that "the free version did not require a Credit Card transaction and was thus way easier to download".

Joost predicts that he would have made a lot more money if the free version was removed and if the minimum purchase was set to $1. Do you think that would have made a difference?

Upcoming Releases
Embark on an inspiring mission of human connection beyond the UCA. Sam — with companions by his side — sets out on a new journey to save humanity from extinction. Join them as they traverse a world beset by otherworldly enemies, obstacles and a haunting question: should we have connected?
Star Citizen is an upcoming space trading and combat simulator video game for Microsoft Windows. Star Citizen will consist of two main components: first person space combat and trading in a massively multiplayer persistent universe and customizable private servers (known as Star Citizen), and a branching single-player game (known as Squadron 42). The game will also feature VR support.
Atlas is an action-rpg with rogue-like elements where you use your ability to control the ground to fight the enemies and move through procedurally generated worlds.
Damnview: Built From Nothing is a simulation sandbox game about occidental culture and its different social classes. Immerse yourself into a decadent urban sprawl, all while working precarious jobs where you will either be absorbed into the system, or cast out of society’s machine. Damnview: Built From Nothing is a game about despair, the hostility of capitalism, and the need…
Reviews
X